Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Lies from the front office

This morning I had a chance to read an article about the Madoff scandal.

It reminded me of a past life experience, in another dimension. No, not anything in line with Shirley MacLaine, I mean several years ago, in another state, etc. In the fall of 2001, just prior to 9/11, I was taking a tax preparation course. The instructor and I were discussing the Enron mess and the dangers of investing an entire 401k into company stock. Enron had been making big returns, and some folks did not anticipate the fall. I asked for the instructors thoughts on the failings of these retirement investment strategies, as well as the security of pension plans. He brushed my question aside, saying that pension plans would never fail. Oops.

I do sympathize with people going through all of this - I really do. My life circumstances have changed so dramatically since 2004 (a $40,000.00 pay cut would hurt anyone), and while I'd love to be earning more money and investing, I ponder this question: "Is it better to have saved/invested and lost, than to be poor and not saved/invested at all?"